Saved

Urban Decay All Nighter vs Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Setting Spray

Urban Decay All Nighter Long-Lasting Setting Spray costs 39% less per ounce: $5.96 / fl oz against $9.80 / fl oz.

Urban Decay

All Nighter Long-Lasting Setting Spray

$23.80 $34

Buy on Amazon

What it is
Setting spray
Size
118 ml, $5.96 / fl oz
On Amazon
Sold by Urban Decay
Amazon best sellers
#4 in Makeup Setting Sprays & Powders
Marked down
30% off on Amazon today

Charlotte Tilbury

Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray

$33.15 $39

Buy on Amazon

What it is
Setting spray
Size
100 ml, $9.80 / fl oz
On Amazon
Sold by Amazon.com
Amazon best sellers
#4 in Makeup Setting Sprays & Powders
Marked down
15% off on Amazon today

Both set makeup with a natural finish; the wear claim and the pitch differ. Urban Decay's All Nighter, reformulated in 2025, is waterproof and claims up to 24 hours. Charlotte Tilbury's Airbrush Flawless claims up to 16 hours and is sold as a hydrating mist, with aloe vera and Japanese green tea, to prime before makeup as well as set it after.

Which one

Urban Decay All Nighter if you want the longer wear claim and a waterproof hold.

Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Setting Spray if you want one mist to prime, set and refresh.

Or a dupe for either

  1. e.l.f. Cosmetics Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist

    for Urban Decay All Nighter Long-Lasting Setting Spray

    $11vs $23.80 $34−32% per oz

    $4.07 / fl oz against $5.96 / fl oz. Both list Glycerin.

    #13 in Makeup Setting Sprays & Powders on Amazon

    A genuinely fine mist that sets makeup rather than spitting wet patches onto it, which is where cheap setting sprays usually fail.

    What it does worse: It finishes a touch dewier than All Nighter's flat lock, and e.l.f. puts the wear time at 16 hours where Urban Decay claims longer.

    Buy on AmazonSee the dupes

  2. Makeup Revolution Infinite Fixing Spray

    for Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Flawless Setting Spray

    $5.23 $10vs $33.15 $39−84% per oz

    $1.55 / fl oz against $9.80 / fl oz. Both list Aloe vera.

    The same film does the holding: AMP-acrylates/allyl methacrylate copolymer, second on Charlotte Tilbury's list and fourth on Revolution's, with polysorbate 20, aloe and fragrance in both.

    What it does worse: Revolution's second ingredient is denatured alcohol, so it dries faster and can sting dry skin, where Charlotte Tilbury's mist has no alcohol and adds PVP to the hold, and Revolution swaps the green tea and mastic for vitamin E, panthenol and horse chestnut.

    Buy on AmazonSee the dupes

Questions

Is there a dupe for Urban Decay All Nighter?

e.l.f. Cosmetics Stay All Night Micro-Fine Setting Mist, about $11, 32% less. A genuinely fine mist that sets makeup rather than spitting wet patches onto it, which is where cheap setting sprays usually fail. It finishes a touch dewier than All Nighter's flat lock, and e.l.f. puts the wear time at 16 hours where Urban Decay claims longer. $11 for 80ml against $36 for 118ml.

Is there a dupe for Charlotte Tilbury Airbrush Setting Spray?

Makeup Revolution Infinite Fixing Spray, about $5.23, 84% less. The same film does the holding: AMP-acrylates/allyl methacrylate copolymer, second on Charlotte Tilbury's list and fourth on Revolution's, with polysorbate 20, aloe and fragrance in both. Revolution's second ingredient is denatured alcohol, so it dries faster and can sting dry skin, where Charlotte Tilbury's mist has no alcohol and adds PVP to the hold, and Revolution swaps the green tea and mastic for vitamin E, panthenol and horse chestnut. The same 100ml bottle for about a fifth of the price.

Amazon prices as of Nov 21, 2026, 6:00 PM ET, subject to change: the price on Amazon at checkout is the one that applies. We may earn a commission; the price you pay is the same.