Prime Big Deal Days Oct 6–7. SHOP THE DEALS ▸

MAC CosmeticsLip Pencil – Spice

Lip liner

$25

MAC Cosmetics

Size 1.45 g, $488.78 / oz

Not sold by Amazon or the brand right now, and we won't send you to a reseller listing we can't vouch for.

Price checked 25 September 2026; Amazon's price today may differ.

No dupe for this one yet

What we checked

  • Rimmel Lasting Finish 1000 Kisses Lip Liner in Spice: Temptalia rates it 100% the same color as MAC Spice, but Amazon.com doesn't sell that pencil. It sells Rimmel's Lasting Finish 8HR liner in a shade also named Spice (110, about $5.60), and we found no swatch of that one against MAC's. Couldn't be checked, 1 October 2026.

What a dupe has to clear, and everything we turned down

Dupes in makeupEvery pair we do have

About the Product

What it is: A warm, medium-dark brown, as Temptalia's swatches describe it, in MAC's creamy, matte-finish wooden lip pencil.

Makeup dupe guides

Lip oil, gloss and plumper dupes10 pairs
Up to −87%Sunscreen dupes with the same UV filters8 pairs
Up to −82%The best beauty dupes under $2012 pairs
Up to −99%Drugstore dupes for high-end makeup that match the finish12 pairs
Up to −93%Dupes that hand you a bigger bottle as well as a lower price12 pairs
Up to −99%Luxury beauty Amazon doesn't stock, and the dupes it does12 pairs
Up to −99%Base makeup dupes12 pairs
Up to −92%Mascara dupes8 pairs
Up to −78%Blush, bronzer and contour dupes12 pairs
Up to −90%Primer and setting spray dupes8 pairs
Up to −80%Korean dupes for high-end skincare, makeup and hair10 pairs
Up to −93%The biggest savings on the site15 pairs
Up to −99%Beauty gifts under $25 that stand in for luxury ones12 pairs
Up to −94%Beauty stocking stuffers under $10 that stand in for luxury ones15 pairs
Up to −94%Gifts for makeup lovers15 pairs
Up to −92%

Alternatives

Other products that do the same job

$25

$488.78 / oz

Not sold by Amazon or the brand right now, and we won't send you to a reseller listing we can't vouch for.