Lip oil, gloss and plumper dupes
Luxury lip oils and glosses are mostly polybutene, esters and a little plant oil, which is why the drugstore versions land so close: Charlotte Tilbury's Collagen Lip Bath and Maybelline's Lifter Gloss share five base ingredients.
What are the best dupes for Dior Lip Glow Oil, Fenty Gloss Bomb and other luxury lip products?
Maybelline Lifter Glaze Oil Balm – Pink Drip, about $6.97 ($70.57 / oz), against the $38 Hourglass Phantom Volumizing Glossy Balm, 89% less.
1. Maybelline Lifter Glaze Oil Balm – Pink Drip
for Hourglass Phantom Volumizing Glossy Balm
$6.97 $8.99vs $38−89% per oz
#30 in Lip Balms & Moisturizers on Amazon
Both are glossy, sheer-tinted balm bullets on the same kind of base, polyglyceryl-2 triisostearate with a phytosteryl dimer dilinoleate, softened with shea butter and kept with vitamin E.
What it does worse: Phantom cools with menthyl lactate for its plumped look and adds diisostearyl malate, mango seed butter and argan and avocado oils; Lifter Glaze has no plumping agent and carries squalane, jojoba butter, hyaluronic acid and acerola extract instead.
2. COVERGIRL Clean Fresh Yummy Gloss
for Dior Addict Lip Glow Oil
$8.98 $11.99vs $40−86% per oz
#37 in Lip Gloss on Amazon
Built on the same base: hydrogenated polyisobutene leads both lists, and both carry polybutene, tridecyl trimellitate and the two styrene copolymers that thicken the oils into a cushiony shine, five of Dior's first nine ingredients.
What it does worse: COVERGIRL's wears a touch thicker and adds castor and sunflower oils and a food scent for each shade, where Dior uses cherry oil and its own fragrance, and its shades are sheer washes rather than Dior's color-reviving tints.
3. e.l.f. Cosmetics Glow Reviver Lip Oil – Pink Quartz
for Dior Addict Lip Glow Oil
$9vs $40−82% per oz
#1 in Lip Gloss on Amazon
Same sheer, high-shine tinted oil worn alone or over lipstick, on a base of apricot, avocado, jojoba and pomegranate oils.
What it does worse: It has a minty scent and cooling tingle Dior's cherry-oil formula does not, and the color stays as it goes on rather than shifting with lip chemistry.
4. essence The Super Peptide Glossy Lip Treatment
for rhode Peptide Lip Tint
$4.97vs $20−75% per oz
#23 in Lip Gloss on Amazon
Shea butter, polybutene and dimer dilinoleyl dimer dilinoleate near the top of both lists, synthetic wax, both forms of vitamin E, and the same peptide, palmitoyl tripeptide-1, in the same carrier of tribehenin, ethylhexyl palmitate and sorbitan isostearate.
What it does worse: The base oil differs: essence starts on polybutene and bis-diglyceryl polyacyladipate-2 where rhode starts on hydrogenated polyisobutene and diisostearyl malate. essence adds bisabolol and is flavored with vanillin; rhode adds babassu oil, cupuaçu butter and a vitamin C ester.
5. MCoBeauty Peptide Lip Treatment – Caramel
for rhode Peptide Lip Treatment
$7.64 $8.99vs $20−75% per oz
#55 in Lip Plumping Treatments on Amazon
Twelve of rhode's ingredients are in MCoBeauty's list: the same glossy base of hydrogenated polyisobutene, diisostearyl malate, shea butter, synthetic wax and octyldodecanol thickened with disteardimonium hectorite, with palmitoyl tripeptide-1 and lactic acid in both.
What it does worse: rhode adds a vitamin C ester, cupuaçu butter and babassu oil, where MCoBeauty adds hyaluronic acid and castor oil, plus peppermint oil and a cooling menthol derivative for a light plumping tingle.
6. NYX Professional Makeup Butter Gloss
for Fenty Beauty Gloss Bomb Universal Lip Luminizer
$5.97vs $22−69% per oz
#3 in Lip Gloss on Amazon
Buttery, non-sticky and almost as shiny, with more shades to choose from.
What it does worse: The gloss film is thinner, so it needs reapplying sooner.
7. Makeup Revolution Juicy Peptide Lip Balm
for rhode Peptide Lip Treatment
$6 $8vs $20−63% per oz
The same lip base at the top of both lists, hydrogenated polyisobutene and then diisostearyl malate, with microcrystalline wax for body, and the same peptide, palmitoyl tripeptide-1, in the same carrier of tribehenin, ethylhexyl palmitate, sorbitan isostearate and lactic acid.
What it does worse: rhode adds shea, babassu and cupuaçu butters and a vitamin C ester; Revolution uses avocado, sunflower and cherry-seed oils with squalane, and it is flavored, with citral, linalool and limonene on the list, where rhode sells an unscented tube. Clear Ice is the untinted shade.
8. Vitamasques Lip Butter Balm – Vanilla Creme
for Summer Fridays Lip Butter Balm
$5.94 $6.99vs $24−63% per oz
#50 in Lip Balms & Moisturizers on Amazon
Same squeeze-tube butter balm with the same vanilla scent, built on plant butters.
What it does worse: Vitamasques adds ceramides, eight types of hyaluronic acid and peptides, and the tube holds 10ml against Summer Fridays' 15g.
9. e.l.f. Cosmetics Thirst Burst Lip Treatment – Sheer Guava
for Ole Henriksen Pout Preserve Hydrating Peptide Lip Treatment
$7.97vs $24−60% per oz
The same six ingredients open both lists, polybutene, hydrogenated polydecene, bis-diglyceryl polyacyladipate-2, a styrene/isoprene gel, microcrystalline wax and silica, and both carry palmitoyl tripeptide-1, the lip peptide.
What it does worse: Ole Henriksen adds a second peptide, palmitoyl hexapeptide-12, with açaí sterols, cloudberry seed oil and kokum butter, where e.l.f. uses cocoa butter, castor oil and a plant-sterol ester; both are sheer, glossy and scented.
10. e.l.f. Cosmetics Squeeze Me Lip Balm
for rhode Peptide Lip Treatment
$5vs $20−58% per oz
#29 in Lip Balms & Moisturizers on Amazon
Same squeeze-tube format and the same glossy, cushiony finish, with shea butter in both formulas.
What it does worse: There is no peptide in e.l.f.'s formula, where hyaluronic acid and goji berry do the conditioning, and each shade carries a sheer tint where the unscented rhode is clear.
How this list was made
What changes is the extra, Dior's cherry oil, Charlotte Tilbury's cooling peppermint, Too Faced's benzyl nicotinate, and the size of the tube, so each comparison names both.




























